ORIENTAL rugs and oriental carpets Notes by Barry O'Connell Spongobongo.com

JBOCs Notes on Oriental Rugs

Dragon Rugs: Prototypical Dragon Carpet Dated 1592

Buy oriental carpets
100% handmade area carpet and rugs from Tibet.
Modern and traditional design. Armenian too!
www.TufenkianCarpets.com
Can't afford Tufenkian Carpets?
Visit the ONLY official Tufenkian carpet outlet.
Discontinued and one of kind rugs.
www.TufenkianOutlet.com
Need a custom area rug?

If you can dream it, we can weave it.
Custom area rugs by Tufenkian

Dragon Rugs: Prototypical Dragon Carpet Dated 1592

Prototypical Dragon Carpet Dated 1592

I have come to the conclusion that there should be carpets dating to around 1600 that are related to the Persian type while beginning to show those signs of degenerative design divergence. There is a dated carpet in the Textile Museum that fits my profile for this early transitional phase Dragon Carpet. The carpet Textile Museum R.36.1.4 is dated November 15, 1592. The late Charles Grant Ellis suggested a somewhat later date for the carpet. With my incredible respect for Ellis, I must note that I find his dating argument in respect to this piece less than compelling. He suggests that it is a later copy by an uneducated weaver who somehow draws the animals on the carpet closer to their 15th and 16th century forebears. Whether this rug is a late 16th century transitional dragon Rug or a nineteenth century copy is immaterial if this is a later copy I still believe that carpets like Textile Museum R.36.1.4 must have been created that looked like Textile Museum R.36.1.4 and would date to when this one was dated.

  • Size: L. 4.45 m. (14',7") x W. 1.83 m. (6'0").
  • Warp: Z2S wool in a light natural range with occasional dark fibers. One level.
  • Weft: Z2S wool in natural mixtures, dyed a good red. Two shots, sometimes three.
  • Pile: 2Z wool. Gordes knotted, pile lies straight. 8 horiz. x l0 1/2 vert. per in. (85 per sq.in.).
  • Sides: Cut.
  • Ends: Cut
  • Colors: Ivory; black-brown; brown, yellow-orange; yellow; dark brick and light rose reds; dark medium and light medium blues; blue-green; light yellow-green; dull light violet.
  • Condition: Some areas rewoven and a great deal of reknotting, now faded. Outer guard lost. Wear has been especially severe along the center line.
Textile Museum.

R 36.1.4

Published: Pope 1925: Ill. 2,
Bode and Kuhnel 1955, 1958: Fig. 40;
Erdmann 1962: Fig. 101;
Ellis 1970: Fig. A.

Textile Museum R.36.1.4 2 inscription and date. November 15, 1592 Textile Museum R.36.1.4 The palmette seems more clearly related to early dragon rugs rather than later rugs. Textile Museum R.36.1.4 The lions are much more closely related to the 16th century prototypes that to 17th century or later dragon rugs.
Textile Museum R.36.1.4 Margin illustrations from the "Golestan of Sa'di" attributed to a Persian Artist Aqa Mirak. Circa 1530

Here we can compare the already derivative Fantastic Animal with it's predecessor. I must conclude that this rug is commercial but derivative of Persian court art. When you see the perfection of Persian Court art it becomes obvious that this is a copy of a copy of a copy. Still it retains enough of the Court influence to make it an obvious missing link between Court Art and Dragon Rugs.

Textile Museum R.36.1.4 Detail from the The Widener Mughal Animal Carpet

I offer this comparison to show the difference between a commercial carpet and a Court workshop carpet.

Detail - Munich's Staat. Museum fur Volkerkunde inventory number 32-50-18  Detail - Textile Museum R.36.1.4 When I see these side by side I am struck by the thought that if this rug is a later copy what was the source carpet to copy from.

The Munich Vase Carpet Fragment is East Persian and is of a style that was widely copied through Persia.

Note: To further a long term research project I am collecting data. When a piece such as this may be of interest to others I have decided to share my notes prior to culmination of the project. As such the attributions are my own unless otherwise stated. Any additions, information, or corrections, would be appreciated.

To See more Caucasian Rugs & Carpets

For Further Reading: Guide to Rugs & Books


Thanks and best wishes,

J. Barry O'Connell Jr.

Persian Rugs the O'Connell Guides

Tabriz Rugs

Kashmar Rugs

Isfahan Rugs

Hamadan Rugs

Mashad Rugs

Gabbeh Rugs

Heriz Rugs

Ardabil Rugs

Lylyan Rugs

Turkmen Rugs

Persian Rugs

Turkish Rugs

Suzani

Oriental Rugs

Persian Carpets

Baluch Rugs,

The Qashqai and Qashqai Rugs

Veramin Rugs

Tribal Rugs

Khotan-Rugs

Khotan-Carpets

Kirman-Rugs

Kirman-Carpets

Antique-Rugs

Antique-Carpets

Shahsevan-Rugs

Oushak-Rugs

Mashad-Rugs

Gabbeh-Rugs

Kurdish-Rugs

Becoming Missional

 

Index to my Rug Notes

How Do I Find An Honest Rug Dealer?

Index

A

B

C

D

E

F

G

H

I

J

K

L

M

N

O

P

Q

R

S

T

U

V

W

X

Y

Z