Persian Miniature Painting: Dragon & Horseman - Sadiqi Beg (?)

Persian Miniature Painting: Dragon & Horseman - Sadiqi Beg (?)
Sotheby's Catalogue Description 1:

A FINE MID-SIXTEENTH CENTURY PERSIAN DRAWING

Lot 214 Sotheby's London UK. 10/22/1993

An unarmed horseman attacked by a Dragon, defending himself with his bare fists as the beast entwines itself about him and the horse, Tabriz or Qazvin, c.1540-50

Ink drawing on paper, seal impression at lower left corner with the name MansurAbd MuzaffarAli (?), mounted on an 18th/19th century Indian album page with undecorated borders and descriptive legend in nagari at top (from the same album as lot 238), 165 by 109mm, page 351 by 240 mm.

This is one of the few drawings attributable to the master artists of Shah Tahmasp's atelier at Tabriz.

On grounds of style it may be assigned to Aqa Mirak, the third painter to take charge of the production of Shah Tahmasp's great Shahnama manuscript after Sultan Muhammad and Mir Musavir. A full account of Aqa Mirak is given by M.B.Dickson and S.C.Welch, The Houghton Shahnameh, Cambridge, 1981, I, 95-117. He came from an Isfahan family of Sayyid descent, and according to Sam Mirza, writing circa 1550, was in close attendance upon the Shah and served as the guiding spirit for the other artists. He is thought to have moved with the court to Qazvin in 1548 and to have worked for Prince Ibrahim at Mashhad after 1556. Although no signed works of his are known, attributions have been made by Welch on the basis of his ascribed miniatures in Shah Tahmasp's Khamsa now in the British Library.

The subject of the lone horseman encountering a dragon was popular with Persian draughtsmen. A slightly later rendering attributed to Sadiqi is in the Sadruddin Aga Khan Collection (A. Welch and S.C.Welch, Arts of the Islamic Book, New York, 1982, no.31; F.R.Martin, Miniature Painting, II, P1.93), and another, attributable to Siyawush, is in the Art and History Trust Collection, (A. Soudavar, Art of the Persian Courts, New York, 1992, no.102).

£10,000-15,000

Tufenkian Carpets Area Rug Sale.


Detail "Dragon & Horseman"

I have questions about the suggestion of an attribution to Aqa Mirak for this piece. I can certainly see similarities to Aqa Mirak but there are some key differences.

Take the top knot of the turban. It has a certain lacey flourish that I expect in the late 16th century or later, not in the mid 16th. It is a little disconcerting because the Taj is drawn in the style of Aqa Mirak in the 1530s so I suspect the artist had access to some of Aqa Mirak's work.

Detail "Dragon & Horseman"

Detail "Attacked by a Dragon" 2.
Attributed to Sadiqi Beg 1590-95

The Dragon reminded more of the work of Sadiqi Beg. It is a nicely drawn dragon and in the style of Sadiqi Beg. Please not the similarities in the horn, the ear, the snout, the ringlets, the bend in the neck, etc...

Obviously I compared this to Plate 102 in Art of the Persian Court" 4. but that dragon has stronger lines and more of that spirit of girift-o gir that we see in great dragons.

Detail "Dragon & Horseman"

Margin illustrations from the "Golestan of Sa'di" attributed to Aqa Mirak. Tabriz Circa 1530 3.

As we can see on the right a dragon by Aqa Mirak is a thing of great beauty. The dragon on the left however is a nice Dragon but not what I expect from the master of girift-o gir.5.

Detail "Dragon & Horseman"

Detail "Attacked by a Dragon"
Attributed to Sadiqi Beg 1590-95

While not exact the legs struck me as similar.

Detail "Dragon & Horseman"

Yuan Dynasty "mei-p'ing" Porcelain Vase 14th century AD

Chinese porcelain was highly prized in Safavid Persia and Mughal India. Here we can see the type of art from which the Persians borrowed the design.

I would like to suggest that this picture should be attributed to Sadiqi Beg in the late 16th or early 17th century. The stamp in the lower left hand corner is thought to be Muzaffar Ali's signature stamp and that this piece then should be attributed to Muzzafar Ali circa 1540. I just do not believe it. That date seems too early by at least 50 years.

Related work


  1. Sotheby's Oriental Manuscripts and Miniatures. London UK. 10/22/1993 Lot 214
  2. Welch, Stuart Cary. and Welch, Anthony Arts of the Islamic Book. Ithaca: Cornell University Press. 1982. page 98 and plate 31.
  3. Soudavar, Abolala. Art of the Persian Court. (New York: Rizzoli, 1992), p. 332 and 333 and cat. no. 136, (folio 6r, 5v)
  4. Girift-o gir is that essence of life that makes the animal look as if it may leap off the page. Literally it means "give and take".
  5. Soudavar, Abolala. Art of the Persian Court. New York: Rizzoli, 1992, plate 102.
  6. Bahari, Ebadollah. Bihzad Master of Persian Painting. London UK.: I. B. Tauris Publishers, 1996 page 228 and plate 128.

For Further Reading:


Thanks and best wishes,

J. Barry O'Connell Jr.

Index to my Rug Notes

How Do I Find An Honest Rug Dealer?

Index

A

B

C

D

E

F

G

H

I

J

K

L

M

N

O

P

Q

R

S

T

U

V

W

X

Y

Z